Indications for Adjuvant (Chemo) Radiotherapy in Vulvar Cancer with Groin Lymph Node Metastases

Jacobus van der Velden*, Ming Tjiong

Amsterdam UMC, location University of Amsterdam, Gynecologic Oncology, Meibergdreef 9, Amsterdam, the Netherlands


Guidelines recommend adjuvant treatment when positive lymph nodes are found after surgical treatment for squamous cell cancer of the vulva except for cases with a single occult intranodal metastasis. Recent studies questioned these recommendations and showed benefit of adjuvant radiotherapy for all patients with positive nodes irrespective of number of nodes. However, these studies did not take into account important nodal characteristics, such as clinical node status, extranodal spread or size of the metastasis. When these variables are taken into account, adjuvant radiotherapy does not seem to result in a better survival for patients with a single occult intranodal metastasis. Whether the addition of chemotherapy to the radiotherapy for patients with more than one positive node or extracapsular spread results in a better survival remains uncertain. Only a few studies have been published on this subject and come to the conclusion that adding chemotherapy results in a better survival. The conclusion is that adjuvant radiotherapy improves survival of patients with positive groin nodes, with the exception of patients with a single intranodal metastasis. The beneficial effect of chemo radiotherapy for subgroups of patients with positive nodes seems likely, although more data are needed before a definite conclusion can be made.


Aim of Review

The aim of this report is to critically review the existing literature on adjuvant therapy in patients with squamous cell cancer (SCC) of the vulva with positive groin lymph nodes after primary surgery. This is performed by a historical overview of published data on this subject. The research questions that we will try to answer are:

  • Does adjuvant radiotherapy or adjuvant concurrent chemo radiotherapy have a beneficial impact on oncological outcome in patients with vulvar cancer and positive lymph nodes?
  • Which patients/subgroups will benefit most from adjuvant therapy? 

Adjuvant Radiotherapy

In 1986 the results of the first and also the only prospective randomized controlled trial (RCT) on the impact of adjuvant radiotherapy on survival in patients with SCC of the vulva and positive groin nodes was published by Homesley et al 1,2. In this study, patients with positive groin nodes were randomized between adjuvant radiotherapy for the groins and pelvis versus adjuvant pelvic node dissection and no further radiotherapy. Disease specific survival was better in the adjuvant radiotherapy group (at 2 years 68% versus 54%; p=0.03). A detailed analysis of this study revealed that the survival gain was mainly due to a decrease in groin recurrences in the adjuvant radiotherapy group. Further subgroup analyses showed that no survival benefit was found for adjuvant radiotherapy in the group of patients with a single positive and clinically occult (not suspicious) node.

As shown in Table 1, the policy of abandoning adjuvant radiotherapy in patients with a single positive lymph node is recommended in most published national guidelines 3-8. All national guidelines take the number of nodes and presence of extra-capsular spread into consideration when recommending adjuvant radiotherapy. Two guidelines (DGGG and GOC) also take size of the metastasis into account 3,6. Until recently the NCCN guideline was the only one, not taking into account the variable extra-capsular spread, although now in the most updated version of the guideline adjuvant radiotherapy is not recommended anymore in patients with a single intracapsular positive node 8.

Table 1: Indications for adjuvant (chemo)radiotherapy in patients with vulvar cancer and positive groin lymph nodes in national guidelines.

 

Number of nodes

Size of metastasis

Extra- capsular

DGGG/DKG 2015[3]

>1

RT if any node ≥ 5 mm/fixed ulcerated node

If yes: RT*

ESGO 2017 [4]

>1

n.m.

If yes: RT or CRT

JSGO 2018 [5]

>1

n.m.

If yes: RT or CRT

GOC/SOGC 2019 [6]

>1 (< 5mm)

RT if any node ≥5 mm

If yes: RT or RCT

RCOG/BGCS 2020 [7]

>1

n.m.

If yes: RT or CRT

NCCN 2023 [8]

>1

n.m.

If yes: RT or CRT

Despite the recommendation to abandon adjuvant radiotherapy in patients with a single intracapsular nodal metastasis in most national guidelines, several older but also more recent studies have questioned this policy, as shown in Table 2 1,9-18.

Table 2: Collated literature data on the impact of adjuvant radiotherapy in patients with squamous cell cancer of the vulva and a single positive lymph node in the groin(s).

 

Source

RT

no RT

Nodal characteristics

RT benefit

Homesley [1]

Hospital

19

17

cN* status

No

Creasman [9]

NCDB

212

no

No

Parthasaraty [10]

SEER

106

102

no

Yes (if ≤ 12 nodes removed)

Fons [11]

Hospital

31

44

yes

No

Woelber [12]

Hospital

14

7

yes

Yes

Mahner [13]

Hospital

77

86

no capsule

No

Swanick [14]

SEER

94

76

no capsule

Yes

Rydzewski [15]

NCDB

816

620

no

Yes

Xanthopoulos [16]

SEER

209

124

no

Yes

Serre [17]

Hospital

28

48

yes capsule, no cN* status

Yes

Van der Velden [18]

Hospital

 

96

yes

No

Surprisingly, 6 out of 11 studies 10,12,14-17 show a benefit of adjuvant radiotherapy even for patients with a single positive lymph node. Five studies, including the previously discussed Homesley study, could not confirm a favorable impact of adjuvant radiotherapy in patients with a single positive node 1,9,11,13.

Studies in Favor of Adjuvant Radiotherapy for Patients with a Single Intracapsular Nodal Metastasis

The main flaw in the majority of the studies is the fact that nodal characteristics are not always taken into account in their analyses. Clinically suspicious nodes, large diameter of the nodal metastasis and especially extra nodal tumor growth are well known poor prognostic variables 19-21. Analyzing the impact of no further treatment in patients with a single positive node is only reliable and scientifically valid when the frequencies of these poor nodal characteristics are reported. Moreover, when comparing the outcome of no further treatment with adjuvant radiotherapy, the groups must be well balanced regarding these important nodal characteristics. Four studies, expressing a preference for adjuvant radiotherapy for all patients, including patients with a single positive node, do not mention these nodal characteristics 10,14-16. Consequently, these studies cannot be used in analyzing the impact of adjuvant (chemo) radiotherapy in patients with a single intracapsular metastasis.

Two studies took into account extracapsular spread and or size of the metastasis in their analyses 12,17. One of the latter studies 12, however, did not provide specific information on extra capsular spread and/or recurrence pattern in the seven reported patients with a single positive lymph node who did not get adjuvant radiotherapy. The other study by Serre and co-workers 17 report on 65 patients with a single intracapsular metastasis and 11 patients with a single extracapsular metastasis. It is not clear what the indications were for adjuvant radiotherapy in 28 patients and for leaving out adjuvant radiotherapy in the other 48 patients. However, in a univariate analysis of the group of patients with a single intracapsular metastasis, adjuvant radiotherapy did not impact on recurrence free and overall survival while in a multivariate analysis adjuvant radiotherapy was an independent favorable prognostic variable for recurrence free survival but not for overall survival. Unfortunately, no comparison of the groin recurrence rate or groin recurrence free survival was available for the two groups (adjuvant radiotherapy versus no adjuvant treatment). This means that it is impossible to define specifically the impact of radiotherapy on the tumor control in the groin in this study. A variable that could theoretically have impact on the groin recurrence rate is the volume of inguino femoral lymph node dissections per surgeon or per institute. In a recently published study 18 at least ten inguino femoral lymph node dissections per year per institute were performed, resulting in a groin recurrence rate of 2.1%, while in the series published by Serre and co-workers 17 analyzing the data of five institutes, only one institute performed > 10 surgical procedures in vulvar cancer, while in the other four institutes only three to nine surgical procedures were performed per year. The groin recurrence rate of 9/65 (14%) patients with a single intracapsular lymph node metastasis in their series compares unfavorable with the 2.1% isolated groin recurrences in the series reported by van der Velden and co-workers.

Studies Showing No Beneficial Impact of Adjuvant Radiotherapy for Patients with a Single Intracapsular Nodal Metastasis

Only one (retrospective) study, analyzing the impact of adjuvant radiotherapy in patients with positive nodes, using the NCDB database 9 came to the conclusion that there was no significant benefit of adjuvant radiotherapy for the total group of patients with positive nodes. However, the group of patients with a single positive node without extracapsular spread was not separately analyzed.

In contrast to the latter study, Mahner and co-workers came to the conclusion that patients with positive nodes benefitted from adjuvant radiotherapy 13. However, they did not observe a significant survival difference with or without adjuvant radiotherapy for the group of patients with a single positive node. Also this study did not take into account extracapsular spread.

In a multicenter case control study, Fons and co-workers analyzed the oncological outcome in a group of 75 patients with a single intracapsular positive node. The oncological outcome did not differ between the group who had adjuvant radiotherapy versus the group who had no further adjuvant treatment 11. In a recently published retrospective multicenter cohort study van der Velden and co-workers analyzed the oncological outcome of 96 patients with a single intracapsular nodal metastasis from four gynecologic oncology centers (three in the Netherlands and one in Australia), all performing a high volume of surgical procedures for vulvar cancer 18. In all three centers the institutional guidelines recommended to abandon adjuvant radiotherapy in patients with vulvar cancer and a single intracapsular metastasis. Three patients (3.1%) were diagnosed with a groin recurrence. Only one patient (1%) had an isolated groin recurrence, although occurring in the contralateral lymph node negative groin. The 5–year disease specific survival for the total group was 79%. On the basis of these favorable results the authors concluded that adjuvant radiotherapy can be safely omitted in patients with a single intracapsular metastasis.

Studies on the Addition of Concurrent Chemotherapy to the Adjuvant Radiotherapy

Only three retrospective studies reported on the oncological outcome after addition of concurrent chemotherapy to the adjuvant radiotherapy 15,22,23. These studies are based on NCDB data from different periods although with overlapping periods in two studies 15,22. Remarks on these studies are that extranodal spread, a known unfavorable prognostic factor, has not been taken into account or it was unclear if this was the case, overall survival was used as endpoint and there was no information on type of surgery. The overall impression was that adding chemotherapy was not beneficial. With overall survival as endpoint, the problem is that in the older age group comorbidity and resultant tendency not to add chemotherapy for that particular group of patients may have impact on the outcome. Three other retrospective studies 24-26 also reported on adjuvant chemoRT both for patients with irradical resection margins and/or positive nodes. However, from these data it was impossible to determine the value of adding chemotherapy to the adjuvant radiotherapy for patients with positive nodes because the latter group was not analyzed separately and also the numbers were very small.

Studies on Adjuvant Chemotherapy

Only one retrospective cohort study has been published on adjuvant chemotherapy (cisplatin) after surgery 27. All 14 patients had more than one positive lymph node and three of them had extranodal growth. After follow-up 2/14 were DOD. The 3 years OS was 86% in this study, which appears to be a very favorable outcome. It has to be remarked that this comprised a very small group of patients. So, more data on this topic with larger amounts of patients are necessary to draw conclusions.

Summary and Conclusions

On the basis of a randomized controlled trial, it can be concluded that adjuvant radiotherapy for patients with SCC of the vulva and positive groin lymph nodes results in a better oncological outcome compared to patients without adjuvant treatment. Although there is some controversy regarding the value of adjuvant radiotherapy for patients with a single intracapsular metastasis, studies taking into account the important prognostic variables such as extranodal spread and size of the metastasis in the node could not show a benefit of adjuvant radiotherapy for that particular group. The addition of concurrent chemotherapy to the adjuvant radiotherapy seems to improve the oncological outcome, although there are limited data to support this, and it is unclear which subgroup of patients might benefit. The impact of adjuvant chemotherapy without radiotherapy has only been studied in one small sized study which makes it impossible to draw firm conclusions. All these arguments result in the fact that most (inter)national guidelines recommend adjuvant radiotherapy (or adjuvant chemo radiotherapy) for patients with more than one positive lymph node or in case extranodal spread is present.

Competing Interests: none declared.

References

  1. Homesley HD, Bundy BN, Sedlis A, et al. Radiation Therapy Versus Pelvic Node Resection for Carcinoma of the Vulva With Positive Groin Nodes. Obstet Gynecol 1986 Dec; 68(6): 733-40.
  2. Kunos C, Simpkins F, Gibbons H, et al. Radiation Therapy Compared With Pelvic Node Resection for Node-Positive Vulvar Cancer, A Randomized Controlled Trial. Obstet Gynecol 2009; 114: 537–46.
  3. Schnürch HG, Ackermann S, Alt CD, et al. Diagnosis, Therapy and Follow-up Care of Vulvar Cancer and its Precursors. Guideline of the DGGG and DKG (S2k-Level, AWMF Registry Number 015/059, November 2015. Geburtsh Frauenheilk 2016; 76: 1035–1049.
  4. Oonk MHM, Planchamp F, Baldwin P, et al. European Society of Gynaecological Oncology Guidelines for the Management of Patients With Vulvar Cancer. Int J Gynecol Cancer 2017; 27: 832-837.
  5. Saito T, Tabata T, Ikushima H, et al. Japan Society of Gynecologic Oncology guidelines 2015 for the treatment of vulvar cancer and vaginal cancer. Int J Clin Oncol. 2018; 23(2): 201–234.
  6. Francis JA, Eiriksson L, Dean E, et al, No. 370. Management of Squamous Cell Cancer of the Vulva. J Obstet Gynaecol Can 2019; 41(1): 89−101.
  7. Morrison J, Baldwin P, Buckley L, et al. British Gynaecological Cancer Society (BGCS) Vulval Cancer Guidelines: Recommendations for Practice. 15 May 2020. https://www.bgcs.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/BGCS-vulval-guidelines-v22.pdf.
  8. Abu-Rustum NR, Yashar CM, Arend R, et al. NCCN Clinical Practice Guidelines in Oncology (NCCN Guidelines®), Vulvar Cancer, Version 1.2023 — December 22, 2022. https://www.nccn.org/professionals/physician_gls/pdf/vulvar.pdf.
  9. Creasman WT, Phillips JL, Menck MR. The National Cancer Data Base Report on Early Stage Invasive Vulvar Carcinoma. Cancer 1997; 80: 505–13.
  10. Parthasarathy A, Cheung MK, Osann K, et al. The benefit of adjuvant radiation therapy in single-node-positive squamous cell vulvar carcinoma. Gynecologic Oncology 2006, 103, 1095–1099.
  11. Fons G, Groenen SMA, Oonk MHM, et al. Adjuvant Radiotherapy in Patients With Vulvar Cancer and One Intra Capsular Lymph Node Metastasis Is Not Beneficial. Gynecol Oncol, 2009 Aug; 114(2): 343-5.
  12. Woelber L, Eulenburg C, Choschzick M, et al, Prognostic Role of Lymph Node Metastases in Vulvar Cancer and Implications for Adjuvant Treatment. International Journal of Gynecological Cancer & Volume 22, Number 3, March 2012.
  13. Mahner S, Jueckstock J, Hilpert F, et al. Adjuvant Therapy in Lymph Node–Positive Vulvar Cancer: The AGO-CaRE-1 Study. JNCI J Natl Cancer Inst, 2015, Vol.107, No.3.
  14. Swanick CW, Eifel PJ, Huo J, et al. Challenges to delivery and effectiveness of adjuvant radiation therapy in elderly patients with node-positive vulvar cancer. Gynecol Oncol 2017, 146, 87–93.
  15. Rydzewski NR, Kanis MJ, Donnelly ED, et al. Role of adjuvant external beam radiotherapy and chemotherapy in one versus two or more node-positive vulvar cancer: A National Cancer Database study. Radiother Oncol 2018; 129(3): 534-539.
  16. Xanthopoulos EP, Grover S, Puri PM, et al. Survival Benefit of Adjuvant Radiation Therapy in Node-positive Vulvar Cancer. American Journal of Clinical Oncology, Volume 41, Number 9, September 2018.
  17. Serre E, Raimond E, Diguisto C, et al. Inguino-femoral radiotherapy in vulvar squamous cell carcinoma: clues to revised indications in patients with only one intracapsular lymph node metastasis. Acta Oncologica 2020, Vol. 59, No. 5, 518–524.
  18. Van der Velden J, Pleunis N, Barlow E, et al. Radiotherapy is not indicated in patients with vulvar squamous cell carcinoma and only one occult intracapsular groin node metastasis. Gynecol Oncol 160 (2021) 128–133.
  19. Homesley HD, Bundy BN, Sedlis A, et al. Assessment of current International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics staging of vulvar carcinoma relative to prognostic factors for survival (a Gynecologic Oncology Group study). American journal of obstetrics and gynecology. 1991; 164: 997-1003.
  20. Origoni M, Sideri M, Garsia S, et al. Prognostic Value of Pathological Patterns of Lymph Node Positivity in Squamous Cell Carcinoma of the Vulva Stage Ill and IVA FIG0. Gynecol Oncol 45, 313-316 (1992).
  21. Luchini C, Nottegar A, Solmi M, et al. Prognostic implications of extranodal extension in node-positive squamous cell carcinoma of the vulva: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Surgical Oncology 25 (2016) 60-65.
  22. Ni L, Sinha S, Rara M, et al. The role of adjuvant radiation therapy in older patients with node-positive vulvar cancer: A national cancer database analysis. Gynecol Oncol 167 (2022) 189–195.
  23. Gill BS, Bernard ME, Lin JE, et al. Impact of adjuvant chemotherapy with radiation for node-positive vulvar cancer: A National Cancer Data Base (NCDB) analysis. Gynecol Oncol 137 (2015) 365–372.
  24. Thomas G, Dembo A, DePetrillo A, et al. Concurrent radiation and chemotherapy in vulvar carcinoma. Gynecol Oncol. 1989 Sep; 34(3): 263-7.
  25. Han SC, Kim DH, Higgins SA, et al. Chemoradiation as primary or adjuvant treatment for locally advanced carcinoma of the vulva. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2000 Jul 15; 47(5): 1235-44.
  26. Mak RH, Halasz LM, Tanaka CK, et al. Outcomes after radiation therapy with concurrent weekly platinum-based chemotherapy or every-3-4-week 5-fluorouracil-containing regimens for squamous cell carcinoma of the vulva. Gynecol Oncol. 2011 Jan; 120(1): 101-7.
  27. Bellati F, Angioli R, Manci N, et al. Single agent cisplatin chemotherapy in surgically resected vulvar cancer patients with multiple inguinal lymph node metastases. Gynecol Oncol. 2005 Jan;96(1):227-31.
 

Article Info

Article Notes

  • Published on: April 17, 2023

Keywords

  • Adjuvant (Chemo) Radiotherapy
  • Groin Lymph Node Metastases
  • squamous cell cancer
  • concurrent chemo radiotherapy

*Correspondence:

Dr. Jacobus van der Velden, MD, PhD,
Amsterdam University Medical Centers Meibergdreef 9, 1105 AZ Amsterdam, The Netherlands; Tel: +31622398302;
Email: j.vandervelden@amsterdamumc.nl

Copyright: ©2023 van der Velden J. This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.